Just being stubborn or could it be PDA? - A child who refuses to do what they are told?

What is Pathological Demand Avoidance?
Pathological Demand Avoidance, often shortened to PDA, is a term used to describe a profile of persistent demand avoidance, commonly associated with autism.
Children who show a PDA profile may experience everyday requests as overwhelming or anxiety-provoking. Things like putting shoes on, choosing a pencil or joining a group activity, can feel difficult.
The word "pathological" can sound alarming. It does not mean that a child is deliberately being awkward or choosing to make life difficult for the adults around them.
It describes a pattern of demand avoidance that can significantly affect everyday life.
It is important to recognise that PDA is not universally recognised as a separate clinical diagnosis. Professionals may use different terminology, and not every child who avoids demands has a PDA profile.
For teachers, the most important thing is understanding the individual child and identifying what helps them feel safe, regulated and ready to learn.
What might PDA look like in a young child.
At this age, children are still developing emotional regulation, communication, flexibility and independence. A child with a PDA profile may experience particular difficulties with everyday expectations.
You might notice:
Wanting control: The child may feel more comfortable when they can decide how, when or where something happens.
Avoiding activities they enjoy: Even a favourite activity can become difficult when it is presented as something they must do.
Saying no frequently: Even when the child wants to take part, they may resist when something is presented as an instruction.
Avoiding everyday routines: Getting dressed, washing hands, lining up, tidying up or moving between activities may become difficult.
Negotiating and questioning: The child may repeatedly question instructions, change the subject or try to take control of the situation.
Using distraction or humour: Joking, pretending not to hear or becoming playful may help them avoid a demand.
Finding transitions difficult: Moving from choosing their own activity to an adult-led task can be particularly challenging.
Becoming distressed unexpectedly: What appears to be a small request to an adult may feel like a significant challenge to the child. These behaviours do not automatically indicate PDA. They are possible signs that a child is experiencing difficulty with demands, anxiety, communication, sensory processing or emotional regulation.
Why does a simple instruction become so difficult?
One of the most important things for school staff to understand is that a child who avoids a request may not be making a conscious decision to be uncooperative.
For children with a PDA profile, demands can trigger a heightened anxiety response.
Examples
What the adult sees:
"It's time to put your things away."
What the child might experience:
"I wasn't ready to stop. I don't know what happens next. I don't want someone else deciding what I have to do. I feel overwhelmed."
The child may respond by refusing, avoiding the task, becoming silly, arguing or becoming distressed.
Instead of asking, "How do I make this child listen?", we can begin asking:
"What is making this difficult for this child, and how can I help?"
Practical strategies for teachers and classroom assistants
Supporting a child with a PDA profile doesn't mean removing all expectations or allowing them to do whatever they want.
We just need to think carefully about how expectations are communicated, how much flexibility is offered and how we build a relationship in which the child feels safe.
1. Build a relationship before placing demands
Connection is often more effective than correction.
Spend time getting to know the child, their interests, their sense of humour and what makes them feel comfortable.
Join in with their play without always directing it. Show genuine interest in what they are doing.
A child who feels understood and accepted may find it easier to trust the adults around them.
2. Reduce direct instructions where possible
Repeated instructions can increase anxiety and resistance.
Instead of:
"Put your coat on now."
Try:
"I wonder if your coat would like to come outside with us?"
Or:
"We're getting ready to go outside. You can decide how you'd like to get ready."
The aim is not to trick the child but to reduce the feeling of being controlled while keeping expectations clear.
Some children prefer direct, clear communication, so always consider the individual child's preferences.
3. Offer genuine choices
Giving children some control can help them feel more comfortable.
Instead of:
"Sit down and start your writing."
Try:
"Would you like to write at the table or on the floor?"
Other examples include:
"Would you like the blue pencil or the green one?"
"Shall we tidy the blocks first or the cars?"
"Would you like to walk beside me or be the line leader?"
Keep choices manageable and meaningful. Avoid offering choices when there is no real flexibility.
4. Use indirect language
Some children respond better to suggestions, invitations and shared thinking than direct commands.
Instead of saying... | Try saying... |
You need to tidy up. | I wonder where these toys might live? |
Come and sit on the carpet. | There's a space over here if you'd like it. |
Start your work. | I wonder what we could do with this first? |
Stop playing. | It's nearly time for something different. |
Put your shoes on. | Your shoes are ready by the door. |
The language should feel natural rather than scripted.
5. Make transitions easier
Transitions can be particularly challenging for young children who find changes and demands difficult.
Try:
Giving gentle advance warnings.
Using visual timetables.
Offering a transition object.
Allowing extra processing time.
Using familiar songs or playful routines.
Giving the child some choice about how they move between activities.
For example, rather than repeatedly telling a child to stop playing and line up, you might invite them to help a favourite toy get ready for the next activity.
6. Reduce unnecessary demands
Think about how many instructions a child receives throughout the school day.
For some children, even small demands can build up.
Consider whether every instruction is essential.
Could the child:
Complete an activity in a different order?
Work in a quieter space?
Have additional time?
Stand rather than sit?
Use a different resource?
Take a movement break?
Complete part of an activity independently?
Small adjustments can make a significant difference.
7. Recognise early signs of anxiety
A child may show signs of becoming overwhelmed before reaching a point where they can no longer manage the situation.
You might notice:
Increased questioning.
Becoming unusually silly or playful.
Becoming restless.
Trying to change the subject.
Repeatedly asking when an activity will finish.
Becoming quiet or withdrawn.
When these signs appear, reduce pressure where possible. Use calm language, give space and offer reassurance.
If a child becomes distressed, prioritise emotional and physical safety rather than trying to secure immediate compliance.
8. Avoid power struggles
One of the most helpful things an adult can do is recognise when a situation is becoming a battle for control.
Repeatedly saying "You must", "I'm the adult" or "You are not doing as you're told" can increase anxiety and make the situation more difficult.
Instead, try to remain calm and flexible.
You might say:
"I can see this feels difficult right now. Let's work out another way."
Or:
"We don't need to solve everything this second. I'm here to help."
This does not mean abandoning boundaries. It means maintaining them in a respectful, supportive way.
Understanding the role of the classroom assistant
Classroom assistants often spend considerable time supporting children through everyday routines, transitions and learning activities.
This puts them in an important position to notice patterns and understand what helps a child feel comfortable.
Consistency between the teacher and classroom assistant is particularly important.
It can help to:
Agree on language and approaches that work for the child.
Share observations about situations that increase anxiety.
Notice what happens before a child avoids a demand.
Record successful strategies.
Communicate regularly with the class teacher and relevant support professionals.
Avoid labelling the child as naughty, manipulative or attention-seeking.
Most importantly, remember that a child's behaviour is communication. Our role is to understand what that communication might be telling us.
Learning and classroom expectations?
A common concern is that adapting our approach might mean a child misses out on learning.
However, supporting a child's emotional regulation and sense of safety can help make learning more accessible. – A safe/relaxed brain is a learning brain and a child able to achieve their full potential
Alternative approaches:
Literacy: Can the child practise writing through a favourite character, story or imaginative game?
Numeracy: Could counting be incorporated into construction, outdoor play or something they enjoy?
Phonics: Could sounds be explored through movement, games or playful activities?
Fine motor skills: Could the child use playdough, construction materials or creative activities rather than always completing a worksheet?
Group activities: Could the child initially participate from the edge of the group before gradually becoming more involved?
The aim is to maintain meaningful learning opportunities while being flexible about how the child accesses them.
Working together with parents and carers
A child may behave very differently at home and at school.
Parents and carers may have spent years developing strategies to help their child manage everyday demands. They can offer valuable insight into triggers, communication preferences, interests and successful approaches.
Rather than focusing conversations solely on difficulties, ask:
What helps your child feel comfortable?
Are there particular situations they find challenging?
What language works well at home?
How do they communicate when they are becoming overwhelmed?
What are their favourite interests and activities?
A positive partnership helps create a more consistent and supportive experience for the child.
Support and guidance available to schools in Northern Ireland
Teachers and classroom assistants do not have to navigate these challenges alone. There are organisations within Northern Ireland that provide information, training and professional guidance.
The following resources are particularly useful for education professionals.
1. Autism NI
Autism NI provides training specifically for education settings, including a course on understanding Pathological Demand Avoidance.
Training is available for teachers, classroom assistants, learning support assistants and other education professionals.
Website: https://autismni.org/
Education training: https://autismni.org/training-courses/training-courses-for-professionals/autism-training-for-education
PDA Society
The PDA Society provides specialist information and practical guidance for professionals supporting children with a PDA profile.
Its education guidance is particularly useful for teachers, classroom assistants, SENCOs and school leaders.
Topics include:
What PDA can look like in education.
Understanding demand avoidance.
Adapting classroom approaches.
Reducing anxiety and unnecessary demands.
Developing supportive relationships.
Website: https://www.pdasociety.org.uk/
Education guidance for professionals: https://www.pdasociety.org.uk/research-professional-practice/education-professional-practice/
Connection before compliance
It is easy to become focused on getting through the school day, completing activities and ensuring that children follow routines.
When a child who experiences demands as overwhelming, the traditional approach of giving instructions and expecting immediate responses may not work.
We need to remember that a child is not giving us a hard time simply because they are finding something difficult.
They are having a hard time themselves.
A child with a PDA profile needs adults who are curious rather than judgemental, flexible rather than confrontational, and supportive rather than punitive.
They still need boundaries, routines and opportunities to learn. However, the way we provide these may need to look different.
Small changes can make a big difference
Working with a child who displays a PDA profile can be challenging, particularly when the strategies that work for other children seem to have little effect.
Understanding can change everything.
When we begin to recognise the possible anxiety behind demand avoidance, we can change our language, adapt our expectations and create an environment where children feel safer and more understood.
We may not always get it right. There will be difficult days, challenging moments and times when we need to rethink our approach.
What matters is our willingness to learn, reflect and keep trying.
Remember: We are not trying to win a battle of wills. We are trying to build a relationship in which a child feels safe enough to learn, grow and thrive.
Before responding to a refusal, consider:
Is this child feeling anxious or overwhelmed?
Have I given too many instructions?
Does the child understand what is expected?
Could I offer more choice or flexibility?
Am I prioritising compliance over connection?
What can I change to make this situation easier?
The most powerful intervention is often not another instruction, reward or consequence.
It is a change in the way we understand the child and in the case of a child with PDA type behaviours less is very often more and choice matters.
Connection. Understanding. Flexibility. Inclusion.
These can make a world of difference to a young child navigating the school day.





Comments